[![Prop-lifting: Please DO NOT do this. It is still STEALING no matter how you look at it.](/proplifting-sign.png)](https://www.reddit.com/r/proplifting/comments/ithsxq/if_its_a_chain_its_free_rein_but_support_your/)

# Proplifting, Plant Piracy, and Dumpster Chocolates {theft}

[^note]: This essay is part of a series on [offensive horticulture](/oh).

## Dumpster Chocolates

"Hey, what are you doing for the rest of the evening? I wanna show you
something."

My friend leads me to an unremarkable parking lot, where we chat about girls and
career goals and music.

Some local folks saunter around the corner, "Hey! You here for the chocolate?"

"Yeah, come join us! My friend Taylor here is visiting from Cali."

"Oh, welcome to town! Nice to meet you both. No, it's alright, we'll come back
another night. It's all yours. Enjoy!"

A few minutes later, a chef-looking character dumps sheets of dark chocolate
into the dumpster and hurries back into the building.

My friend pulls out two grocery bags from his pocket, and we skim ~10 lbs. of
chocolate off the top of the dumpster.

Apparently gourmet chocolate shops make batches unsuitable for customers, but
perfectly suitable for low-lifes like me.

## Dumpster Law

According to
[_California v. Greenwood_](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_v._Greenwood),
dumpster diving is totally legal on public property if there are no superceding
local laws.

But trash isn't legal treasure in many US municipalities. Most populous
cities/towns have laws against "scavenging" (albeit with selective enforcement).

[^note]:
    Throughout this series, I'll continue to offer my narrow US-centric
    perspective. If you have any wisdom to add from other corners of the world,
    please [email me](mailto:hello@taylor.town) and I'll add a footnote.

## Props

Brief horticulture detour:
[plants can reproduce asexually](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_propagation).
To create a genetic clone of a plant, sever it in a spot rich with stem cells,
then leave that tip in water or soil. Your cutting will grow roots and life will
go on.

## Honor Among Thieves

[![Proplifting on Wikipedia](/proplifting-wikipedia.png)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proplifting)

> ["If it's a chain it's free rein, but support your local nursery!"](https://www.reddit.com/r/proplifting/comments/ithsxq/if_its_a_chain_its_free_rein_but_support_your/)

Many proplifters abide by
[pirate codes](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_code).

Corporations like Walmart and Home Depot sell plenty of plants. Lowe's alone
[sold $9B of lawn and garden supplies in 2022](https://corporate.lowes.com/sites/lowes-corp/files/2022-04/Lowe-2021-Annual-Report.pdf).
Some proplifters believe that such sales volumes justify direct theft by
cutting/tearing live plants.

"Dumpster chocolate" proplifters draw boundaries at "floor finds", i.e. they
only take plant matter they believe will be thrown away. This rarely occurs on
public property (it's theft!).

## Public Gardens, Private Property

[![](/obliqua-confession.png)](https://imgur.com/gallery/uZpWxCj)

[![](/proplifting-response.png)](https://www.reddit.com/r/whatsthedirt/comments/idg2ym/multiple_accounts_of_experiences_with_aroiddaddy/g2j1lic/)

[^note]:
    Nitpick: Proplifting from a publicly-accessible private garden is theft, not
    poaching.

In 2020, a plant influencer stole cuttings of _Monstera obliqua peru_ from the
Huntington Botanical Gardens and publicly confessed to the crime. This was at
the height of
[the obliqua hype cycle](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZRdeeLN6kIM).

The San Diego Botanic Garden
[is a another target for plant theft](https://fox5sandiego.com/news/local-news/experts-warn-of-houseplant-black-market-after-thief-targets-botanic-garden/),
fueled by that same fervor for blackmarket houseplants.

Botanic gardens are havens for conservation, but jealous souls see that verdant
sprawl and their eyes turn green, green, green. They mistake that abundance for
surplus.

## Front Yard, Fair Game?

Private plants overhanging _your_ property
[are fair game](https://www.sacbee.com/news/california/article279016779.html).

Private plants overhanging _public_ property
[are sometimes fair game](https://www.sacbee.com/news/california/article279204989.html).

Harvest dumpster chocolates with caution.

## How to Politely Ask for a Cutting

If you notice a particularly nice plant variety in somebody's yard or home:

1. Approach the envied plant owner.
2. Compliment their lovely home and splendid taste in plants.
3. Ask if they know where they purchased the coveted plant.
4. Ask if you can take a small cutting. Offer to propagate a plant for them as
   well.